Friday, October 16, 2009

Radio shipping costs county a boatload

Park County typically pays out well over $1 million a month meeting payroll and other expenses. Commissioners sign off on hundreds of bills every couple weeks, usually with little to no discussion.

However, one unusual bill drew their attention last week -- a $580.25 invoice to ship five radios.

“They must have been heavy,” quipped Commissioner Jill Shockley Siggins.

After a closer look at the voucher, commissioners found it was actually the insurance costs that drove up the freight costs at Cody's UPS Store.

County CIO Mike Conners submitted the bill, which he readily called, “crazy”* in a conversation with the Tribune.

“I figured that might raise a red flag somewhere,” he said.

The $5,000 radios - only about five years old - had been removed from some older, soon-to-be decommissioned patrol cars from the sheriff's department, Conners said. The communication devices were being shipped out to Veto Enterprises in Sycamore, Ill., where they'll be installed in shiny new squad cars.

“The radios are still in good shape,” Conners said.

Making sure they stayed that way was the big financial burden -- UPS insurance on the pricey items cost just under $60 per radio.

“I didn’t dare not insure them for five grand a piece,” said Conners.

Because if they did get destroyed, and Conners had to submit a $25,000 bill for their replacement?

“Then I’d get some questions, I suppose,” he said.

Last Tuesday, commissioners were satisfied with a second look at the receipt.

“Sometimes you wonder, you know?” said Commission Chairman Bill Brewer, who initially inquired about the expense. “We just get a bill and approve it.”

*Consider this: it's about 1,250 miles to Sycamore from Cody, which Google Maps conservatively estimates as a 21-hour drive. So if you paid someone $12 an hour to deliver just the radios in a vehicle getting 15 miles per gallon (at $2.50 a gallon), it would cost only $460. Granted, that doesn't cover any insurance. (An addition: As anon points out in the comments, that figure is also assuming that the driver lives in Sycamore or something, and has no need to return to Cody. The number would double to $920 for going both ways, which makes UPS cheaper. Of course, the the UPS price doesn't include return delivery, either. At a doubled-bill it would tally $1,160.50. I guess the point is that this comparison is clunky.)

5 comments:

  1. At 1250 miles EACH WAY, your $460 estimate is way off. Also factor in meals, hotels and it was far less expensive to ship via UPS even with the insurance.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Excellent point, anon - you're right on the money. I'll correct my fuzzy math; apologies for screwing that up.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As much as I hate to correct a correction, I've got to add this after thinking some more about my math: the shipping is only one way, too. So really, if we're going to try compare the two delivery methods, we'd have to double the shipping cost too.

    Then again, maybe I'll just say that your point is well taken that my comparison is pretty rough and leave it at that. The only aim of the math was to show that $580 is a lot of money, especially compared to what you and I pay to ship our everyday stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Agreed...$580 is way spendy for shipping of anything.the evils in life.insurance and lawyers.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The question that the Tribune should investigate is how this story relates to the "Sheriff Chastised" story. Are these radios related to the new vehicles purchased by the sheriff?

    ReplyDelete